Free to read · free account to contributeSuccessor to Anticars (2000)
Sign inCreate account
MECAFILE · COMMUNITY VALIDATED · MECAFILE ·m
ModerateNAMecafile analysis of official data

Transmission and drivetrain: problems reported by owners

Last edited 5 days ago by Mecafile1 revisions

36 owners in the United States reported problems with the transmission and drivetrain of this car to NHTSA (model years 2001–2006), typically at around 66,000 miles. Most often named: manual transmission (28%), automatic transmission (19%). Reported consequences: 2 crashes.

What owners describe

“Smg hydraulic pump: I was driving on the highway at 65 mph in the #1 lane and my car all of a sudden dropped out of gear and my car started to coast losing speed very fast, I looked at my speedometer and it was 45 mph. Cars were honking and high beaming me but I was helpless and was trying to move to the right with my hazard lights on. All of a sudden the car kicked back into gear, I was able to…” (2003 model, 119,000 miles)

“The smg transmission intermittently comes out of gear in any situation and is very dangerous when in heavy traffic and/or on a highway and loose all power. I have had several close call accidents at high speeds. I have read many articles stating the same issue with many owners for this type of transmission with a possible defective heat sensor on the hydraulic pump. Bmw refuses to recognize this…” (2006 model, 104,000 miles)

“Smg transmission light came on and randomly went into neutral while driving down the four lane and almost caused an accident. Light went off and it seemed fine l for a couple weeks and same happened again when I was on the interstate taking my son to the hospital. I called bmw and was informed that there wasnt a recall on the transmission and therefore it isnt deemed an issue on thier end. I told…” (2005 model, 88,000 miles)

About these figures

Complaints are filed by owners with the US safety agency NHTSA and are not verified by it. They show where owners run into problems, not how often the problem occurs. If you know the cause or the repair, please add it.

Sources

  1. NHTSA owner complaints (United States, public domain)