Free to read · free account to contributeSuccessor to Anticars (2000)

Dashboard

Makes and models ranked from the data on Mecafile: defects documented by the community and official recalls. Figures are recalculated once a day.

Updated Nov 18, 2026 · 10,685 defects · 6,295 recalls

Makes

Most documented defects

  1. 1Volkswagen815
  2. 2Ford677
  3. 3Mercedes-Benz626
  4. 4Nissan610
  5. 5Toyota572
  6. 6Chevrolet487
  7. 7BMW469
  8. 8Audi443
  9. 9Hyundai412
  10. 10Renault406
  11. 11Peugeot370
  12. 12Honda362
  13. 13Kia360
  14. 14Citroën352
  15. 15Volvo328

Most recalls

  1. 1Mercedes-Benz783
  2. 2Peugeot434
  3. 3Citroën403
  4. 4Opel390
  5. 5Ford372
  6. 6Volkswagen371
  7. 7BMW360
  8. 8Renault241
  9. 9Audi240
  10. 10Toyota199
  11. 11Jeep189
  12. 12Land Rover181
  13. 13Hyundai176
  14. 14Porsche161
  15. 15Fiat146

Most reliable

#MakeIndexDefectsRecallsCriticalGenerations
1Infiniti11.546152813
2LanciaLancia12.534271911
3GenesisGenesis12.6344167
4Škoda15.680856925
5Alfa RomeoAlfa Romeo15.692333117
6LexusLexus17.0128569827
7Dacia17.074644017
8Cadillac17.6111337320
9Audi17.944324025088
10Porsche17.910116111135
11Smart18.43227177
12Suzuki18.5174677728
13Renault19.640624119172
14SEAT19.9130987626
15Fiat20.224814612143

Least reliable

#MakeIndexDefectsRecallsCriticalGenerations
1Tesla89.815140895
2Jeep59.425518919918
3Mercedes-BenzMercedes-Benz43.862678361877
4Land RoverLand Rover43.37018111014
5DodgeDodge41.41448812514
6Chrysler36.92055212617
7SaabSaab33.3830396
8Opel32.626139021245
9Citroën32.235240322051
10Peugeot31.937043422054
11Ford31.367737239877
12Mazda30.925611012927
13Volkswagen29.981537138589
14Kia28.636011426541
15Volvo28.332814419039

Models

Most documented defects

  1. 1Volkswagen Golf177
  2. 2Audi A4132
  3. 3Mercedes-Benz C-Class115
  4. 4Volkswagen Passat115
  5. 5BMW 5 Series90
  6. 6BMW 3 Series86
  7. 7Volkswagen Jetta79
  8. 8Renault Clio74
  9. 9Kia Sportage72
  10. 10Jeep Grand Cherokee70
  11. 11Kia Sorento69
  12. 12Honda Civic68
  13. 13Volkswagen Polo68
  14. 14Audi A665
  15. 15Toyota Corolla64

Most recalls

  1. 1Mercedes-Benz C-Class182
  2. 2Mercedes-Benz E-Class153
  3. 3Land Rover Range Rover143
  4. 4Mercedes-Benz Sprinter122
  5. 5Peugeot 208121
  6. 6Peugeot 3008107
  7. 7BMW X3106
  8. 8BMW 3 Series103
  9. 9Citroën Jumpy102
  10. 10Peugeot 308101
  11. 11Peugeot EXPERT100
  12. 12Mercedes-Benz GLC100
  13. 13BMW X195
  14. 14Citroën C394
  15. 15Opel Grandland84

Most reliable

#ModelIndexDefectsRecallsCriticalGenerations
1Mercedes-Benz V-Class6.710023
2Chrysler Voyager8.410875
3Mazda Premacy8.58012
4Volvo 7409.010073
5Nissan Townstar9.310443
6Suzuki Wagon R9.510012
7Opel Tigra9.510012
8SEAT Córdoba10.011012
9Audi S410.2171166
10Fiat Palio11.08001
11Audi A111.58242
12Genesis G8011.58152
13SEAT Toledo12.081294
14Porsche 91113.015402110
15Hyundai i1013.38973

Least reliable

#ModelIndexDefectsRecallsCriticalGenerations
1Opel Arena213.01576351
2Mercedes-Benz E-Class177.3641531033
3Peugeot 208159.521121442
4Land Rover Range Rover148.735143913
5Tesla Model S141.04117291
6BMW X1140.52095522
7Mercedes-Benz Sprinter137.050122703
8Volkswagen Tiguan124.52680382
9BMW X3124.040106843
10Porsche Taycan124.01139251
11Tesla Model X121.03514271
12Jeep Cherokee120.01639141
13Mercedes-Benz C-Class117.71151821256
14Citroën C4 Cactus116.01637151
15Tesla Model 3115.03715191

How the reliability index works

Each documented defect (not disputed) and each official recall counts 3 points when critical, 2 when moderate and 1 when minor. The total is divided by the number of generations with at least one entry, so a make with many models is not penalised for its size. The lower the index, the more reliable.

Only ranked with enough data: makes need at least 25 entries over 3 generations, models at least 8 entries. Both also need documented defects, not only recalls: at least 30 for a make and 8 for a model.