Free to read · free account to contributeSuccessor to Anticars (2000)

Dashboard

Makes and models ranked from the data on Mecafile: defects documented by the community and official recalls. Figures are recalculated once a day.

Updated Nov 18, 2026 · 562 defects · 0 recalls

Makes

Most documented defects

  1. 1Honda97
  2. 2Renault76
  3. 3Fiat70
  4. 4Ford69
  5. 5Toyota67
  6. 6Hyundai64
  7. 7Opel44
  8. 8Citroën29
  9. 9Nissan20
  10. 10Peugeot20
  11. 11Isuzu5
  12. 12Chevrolet1

Most recalls

Not enough data yet for this market.

Most reliable

#MakeIndexDefectsRecallsCriticalGenerations
1Fiat9.07001015
2Renault16.9760189
3Toyota16.9670319

Least reliable

#MakeIndexDefectsRecallsCriticalGenerations
1Honda36.0970356
2Opel22.344094
3Hyundai19.4640358

Models

Most documented defects

  1. 1Honda Civic97
  2. 2Toyota Corolla50
  3. 3Renault Clio49
  4. 4Ford Transit33
  5. 5Hyundai Accent32
  6. 6Opel Astra26
  7. 7Renault Mégane24
  8. 8Nissan Qashqai15
  9. 9Opel Corsa13
  10. 10Ford Escort13
  11. 11Hyundai Sonata13
  12. 12Ford Transit Connect13
  13. 13Citroën Jumpy10
  14. 14Fiat Tipo10
  15. 15Fiat Ducato9

Most recalls

Not enough data yet for this market.

Most reliable

#ModelIndexDefectsRecallsCriticalGenerations
1Fiat Tipo10.510012
2Fiat Palio11.08001
3Citroën Berlingo12.08011
4Toyota Verso13.08021
5Renault Mégane13.724023
6Ford Escort14.513042
7Citroën Jumpy16.010021
8Fiat Bravo/Brava16.08011
9Fiat Tempra17.08011
10Fiat Ducato18.09031
11Hyundai Lavita21.09041

Least reliable

#ModelIndexDefectsRecallsCriticalGenerations
1Honda Civic36.0970356
2Nissan Qashqai33.015071
3Hyundai Sonata33.013081
4Opel Astra27.026062
5Ford Transit Connect27.013041
6Opel Corsa27.013031
7Renault Clio26.3490154
8Hyundai Accent26.0320183
9Ford Transit24.7330133
10Toyota Corolla24.2500275
11Citroën C2522.08061

How the reliability index works

Each documented defect (not disputed) and each official recall counts 3 points when critical, 2 when moderate and 1 when minor. The total is divided by the number of generations with at least one entry, so a make with many models is not penalised for its size. The lower the index, the more reliable.

Only ranked with enough data: makes need at least 25 entries over 3 generations, models at least 8 entries. Both also need documented defects, not only recalls: at least 30 for a make and 8 for a model.