Free to read · free account to contributeSuccessor to Anticars (2000)

Dashboard

Makes and models ranked from the data on Mecafile: defects documented by the community and official recalls. Figures are recalculated once a day.

Updated Nov 18, 2026 · 1,996 defects · 0 recalls

Makes

Most documented defects

  1. 1Volkswagen286
  2. 2BMW190
  3. 3Hyundai172
  4. 4Mercedes-Benz172
  5. 5Toyota115
  6. 6Peugeot110
  7. 7Mazda88
  8. 8Jeep84
  9. 9Nissan81
  10. 10Kia78
  11. 11Honda75
  12. 12Chevrolet58
  13. 13Dacia54
  14. 14Ford53
  15. 15Opel52

Most recalls

Not enough data yet for this market.

Most reliable

#MakeIndexDefectsRecallsCriticalGenerations
1Citroën12.0480118
2Dacia13.3540178
3Nissan14.48104414
4Ford17.6530217
5Opel18.0520116
6Honda19.7750319
7Peugeot21.411002610
8Toyota22.211506513
9Mazda23.1880419

Least reliable

#MakeIndexDefectsRecallsCriticalGenerations
1Mercedes-BenzMercedes-Benz45.01720749
2Jeep43.0840505
3Volkswagen30.328609321
4Hyundai28.417209715
5Volvo28.3400113
6Kia27.9780467
7Renault26.3350113
8Chevrolet25.6580235
9BMW25.419009918

Models

Most documented defects

  1. 1Volkswagen Golf140
  2. 2Mercedes-Benz C-Class82
  3. 3Toyota Corolla77
  4. 4BMW 5 Series76
  5. 5BMW 3 Series51
  6. 6Volkswagen Jetta51
  7. 7Honda Civic50
  8. 8BMW X340
  9. 9Hyundai Accent39
  10. 10Hyundai i3037
  11. 11Mazda Mazda335
  12. 12Hyundai Santa Fe33
  13. 13Opel Astra32
  14. 14Jeep Cherokee31
  15. 15Volvo S4031

Most recalls

Not enough data yet for this market.

Most reliable

#ModelIndexDefectsRecallsCriticalGenerations
1Mitsubishi Triton8.312043
2Isuzu D-Max9.714033
3Toyota Hilux10.58062
4Fiat Palio11.08001
5Citroën Berlingo12.08011
6SEAT Ibiza12.318023
7Toyota HiAce12.511032
8Dacia Logan13.013052
9Daihatsu Cuore14.08011
10Opel Corsa14.320053
11BMW 7 Series14.3150133
12Nissan Hardbody Truck15.011082
13Škoda Fabia15.514052
14Peugeot 50816.011001
15Daihatsu Terios16.08011

Least reliable

#ModelIndexDefectsRecallsCriticalGenerations
1Jeep Cherokee79.0310181
2Mercedes-Benz Sprinter65.0270121
3Mercedes-Benz C-Class61.0820283
4Chevrolet Aveo55.024091
5Mercedes-Benz E-Class54.0220111
6Jeep Liberty54.0210131
7Volkswagen Golf52.21400486
8Renault Clio47.020081
9Chrysler Town & Country44.020071
10Hyundai Tucson43.0160111
11BMW 3 Series41.3510273
12Land Rover Freelander41.018081
13Kia Sephia41.017081
14Hyundai Santa Fe40.0330172
15Volkswagen Jetta39.0510193

How the reliability index works

Each documented defect (not disputed) and each official recall counts 3 points when critical, 2 when moderate and 1 when minor. The total is divided by the number of generations with at least one entry, so a make with many models is not penalised for its size. The lower the index, the more reliable.

Only ranked with enough data: makes need at least 25 entries over 3 generations, models at least 8 entries. Both also need documented defects, not only recalls: at least 30 for a make and 8 for a model.