Free to read · free account to contributeSuccessor to Anticars (2000)

Dashboard

Makes and models ranked from the data on Mecafile: defects documented by the community and official recalls. Figures are recalculated once a day.

Updated Nov 18, 2026 · 18,857 defects · 32,736 recalls

Makes

Most documented defects

  1. 1Ford1,619
  2. 2Chevrolet1,201
  3. 3Toyota1,179
  4. 4Nissan1,010
  5. 5Honda847
  6. 6Volkswagen822
  7. 7Mercedes-Benz740
  8. 8Dodge581
  9. 9Hyundai552
  10. 10BMW524
  11. 11Mazda519
  12. 12Kia484
  13. 13Audi451
  14. 14Renault412
  15. 15Subaru410

Most recalls

  1. 1Mercedes-Benz3,534
  2. 2Ford2,839
  3. 3BMW1,879
  4. 4Toyota1,583
  5. 5Nissan1,485
  6. 6Chevrolet1,428
  7. 7Volkswagen1,289
  8. 8Peugeot1,127
  9. 9Honda1,084
  10. 10Hyundai1,054
  11. 11Audi1,003
  12. 12Dodge996
  13. 13Jeep990
  14. 14Citroën952
  15. 15Mazda832

Most reliable

#MakeIndexDefectsRecallsCriticalGenerations
1DaihatsuDaihatsu9.31201215456
2LanciaLancia11.834342113
3Toyota18.61,1791,583997337
4Smart19.133552310
5Dacia19.4741014619
6IsuzuIsuzu19.4781417826
7Suzuki19.634242021485
8Škoda19.6801549428
9Alfa RomeoAlfa Romeo21.9921306322
10SEAT24.013016210228
11Nissan24.51,0101,485850230
12Honda25.58471,084695173
13Mitsubishi25.7364811349102
14Renault28.341263928281
15Fiat28.824939518449

Least reliable

#MakeIndexDefectsRecallsCriticalGenerations
1Tesla123.41632331237
2Jeep109.333199049828
3Mercedes-BenzMercedes-Benz100.87403,5341,39897
4Land RoverLand Rover91.515173629522
5JaguarJaguar65.19845622020
6SaabSaab61.911018011611
7LincolnLincoln59.523049226828
8Ford58.31,6192,8391,750179
9DodgeDodge57.858199668465
10Peugeot55.63711,12736858
11GMCGMC54.929546429632
12BMW53.85241,879924104
13Volvo52.734875839048
14Mini50.56519911012
15Citroën49.635295233357

Models

Most documented defects

  1. 1Volkswagen Golf177
  2. 2Ford F-Series138
  3. 3Honda Civic135
  4. 4Audi A4132
  5. 5Honda Accord123
  6. 6Mercedes-Benz C-Class115
  7. 7Volkswagen Passat115
  8. 8BMW 3 Series109
  9. 9Toyota Camry108
  10. 10Ford Taurus105
  11. 11Toyota Corolla98
  12. 12Ford Explorer98
  13. 13BMW 5 Series94
  14. 14Mercedes-Benz E-Class92
  15. 15Dodge Caravan91

Most recalls

  1. 1Mercedes-Benz C-Class713
  2. 2Mercedes-Benz E-Class713
  3. 3BMW 3 Series533
  4. 4Mercedes-Benz S-Class531
  5. 5BMW 5 Series499
  6. 6BMW X5485
  7. 7Mercedes-Benz GLE-Class455
  8. 8Mercedes-Benz Sprinter437
  9. 9Land Rover Range Rover409
  10. 10BMW X3400
  11. 11Dodge Ram398
  12. 12Ford F-Series390
  13. 13BMW 7 Series373
  14. 14Mercedes-Benz GLC370
  15. 15Jeep Grand Cherokee359

Most reliable

#ModelIndexDefectsRecallsCriticalGenerations
1Volkswagen LT8.58122
2Nissan Townstar8.810754
3Nissan Skyline9.182427
4Toyota Passo10.081044
5Chevrolet Tracker10.310453
6Opel Omega10.78743
7Toyota Tercel10.8157125
8Fiat Palio11.08001
9Nissan Sunny11.8109104
10Ford Laser12.0161144
11Daihatsu Terios12.010132
12Toyota Hilux12.81533239
13Nissan Pulsar14.01619156
14Toyota Vellfire14.0111744
15Volvo 74014.010793

Least reliable

#ModelIndexDefectsRecallsCriticalGenerations
1Ford E-Series372.0902201322
2Mercedes-Benz Sprinter367.0504371513
3BMW X3357.7404002053
4BMW X1330.0202661032
5BMW X5317.0404852464
6Tesla Model S316.041101441
7Mercedes-Benz C-Class314.81157132636
8Mercedes-Benz E-Class310.2927132716
9BMW X7308.010128461
10Porsche Taycan308.011121501
11Mercedes-Benz GLC306.0253701363
12Ford F-Series thirteenth generation296.011115471
13Mercedes-Benz GLE-Class291.8614551594
14Volvo XC60288.023229852
15Tesla Model 3287.037104271

How the reliability index works

Each documented defect (not disputed) and each official recall counts 3 points when critical, 2 when moderate and 1 when minor. The total is divided by the number of generations with at least one entry, so a make with many models is not penalised for its size. The lower the index, the more reliable.

Only ranked with enough data: makes need at least 25 entries over 3 generations, models at least 8 entries. Both also need documented defects, not only recalls: at least 30 for a make and 8 for a model.